Joining Half Moon Bay and San Carlos, Millbrae Will Outsource Police Department to Sheriff

With last night's decision to outsource their police force to the San Mateo County Sheriff's Office, Millbrae joined and San Carlos as the third city in the county to contract out law enforcement services to the agency.

The Millbrae City Council approved the decision in a 3-2 vote late Tuesday with council members Paul Seto and Nadia Holober dissenting.

Last week, the sheriff resubmitted an after residents overwhelmingly opposed disbanding the Millbrae Police Department, claiming that the original outsourcing offer was inadequate. The city expects to save about $1.1 million a year with the sheriff’s deal, but will staff four fewer police employees.

“We had two town-hall meetings and we listened to the public,” said Mayor Dan Quigg, referring to the Nov. 1 and Nov. 5 sessions on police services held in the Chetcuti Room. 

However, the majority of people that spoke at the council meeting were still unsatisfied with the revised proposal.

“It is still just a baseline proposal,” said Millbrae Traffic Sgt. Ron Gleeson. “Dave Chetcuti Jr., [a crime analyst with the MPD] whose father gave his life to this city, is not included.”

Some employees’ positions, including Chetcuti’s and the Millbrae Police Volunteers, have yet to be addressed.

As a result, the public and two council members proposed the city delay its decision until it receives more detailed information and perhaps wait for the new council members to govern.

“We’ve waited seven years to get to this point, I don’t see why we can’t wait for the next council to make a decision,” said Paul Seto, who will be relinquishing his council seat.

And Holober, who on the other hand will remain on the council, also agreed.

However, some police officers urged the council to act swiftly and favored the sheriff’s proposal.

“Millbrae cannot wait for another study, and neither can we,” said Traffic Officer Gaby Chaghouri, who stood in front of the council with seven other officers who were all eager to work at the Sheriff’s Office.

“[The sheriff] offers us leadership and opportunity in career training,” he said.

The Sheriff’s Office will hire every sworn and non-sworn full-time Millbrae police employee, according to San Mateo County Undersheriff Carlos Bolanos.

But, the sheriff said he would hold the positions open until the end of December, compelling the council to act quickly.

“Our priority is to ensure public safety, and regrettably, this has to be done now,” said Councilwoman Gina Papan.  

Rather than securing public safety for the city, some residents worried outsourcing would jeopardize it.

“Contracting out the Police Department will create a negative impact on our businesses, schools and property values,” said Joe Chen on behalf of the Peninsula Chinese Business Association.

That perception, however, may be unfounded. San Carlos City Manager Jeff Maltbie said that he was very pleased with the Sheriff’s Office, and Half Moon Bay city councilmembers have echoed the sentiment about the after contracting out services since June.

San Carlos outsourced its 85-year-old police department to the Sheriff’s Office on Oct. 31, 2010.

In a year, San Carlos conducted two studies on the sheriff’s level of service. The average emergency response time had not changed, and Part 1 crimes, such as rapes, murders, aggravated assault and robbery, decreased slightly.

San Carlos also conducted two surveys measuring residents’ satisfaction with the Sheriff’s Office. Out of the 102 surveys completed, citizens were 98 percent satisfied with services. 

“[The Sheriff’s Office] has come through on all its promises and it has made an effort to really integrate into our community,” Maltbie said.

But Millbrae is not like San Carlos, which neighbors Redwood City, said Wayne Lee, who will soon become a councilman.

Lee helped collect about 480 signatures of residents who wanted to save the Millbrae Police Department, even by imposing a tax.

Millbrae would need to wait until June 2012 to place a measure on the ballot, which during a special election requires two-thirds approval.

City Council members could have opted to spend an additional $410,000 a year to fund the Police Department and begin searching for a police chief, since Chief Neil Telford will return to San Bruno on Friday.

“We don’t have that money,” Quigg said. “We have a dysfunctional department right now. We have worked on this for months. We had two town-hall meetings and listened to the public.”

Millbrae will now negotiate with the Sheriff’s Office to determine the exact scope of services and plan the transition.

To receive news feeds about Half Moon Bay and the unincorporated Coastside between Montara and Pescadero, visit Half Moon Bay Patch on Facebook and "like" us here. Follow us on Twitter here.