Kids & Family

La Jolla High Grad’s ‘Lost Girls’ Is Finalist for San Diego Book Award

Former Union-Tribune reporter was a finalist last year as well—for "Poisoned Love" on Kristin Rossum case.

When Caitlin Rother launched Lost Girls, her account of how sex-offender John Gardner became the monster who raped and killed, she upset the families of teen victims Chelsea King and Amber Dubois.

On Thursday, Rother’s true-crime book drew a different reaction: praise.

Lost Girls was listed as a finalist for a San Diego Book Award. 

Rother, a 1980 La Jolla High School graduate and former Union-Tribune reporter, said she entered an earlier book, Poisoned Love, last year.

“It was chosen as a finalist but lost out to two other books that tied (one on local breweries and one on Chula Vista history), which made me realize that [Local Interest] wasn’t the appropriate category,” Rother said. 

She says she spoke with one of the organizers of the prestigious local award, and entered her latest book in the Local Biography/History category.

Other finalists in that category are:

  • An American Girl in the Hawaiian Islands: Letters of Carrie Prudence Winter, 1890-1893, Sandra Bonura and Deborah Day, eds. 
  • I Got a Name: The Jim Croce Story by Ingrid Croce and Jimmy Rock 
Also up for a book award is celebrity chef Brian Malarkey, who operates the chain of fabric-themed restaurants including Herringbone in La Jolla and Burlap in Del Mar.

Malarkey’s Come Early, Stay Late is in the Cookbook and Entertaining category and is joined as a finalist by:
  • Photographs and Memories: Recipes from Croce’s Restaurant and Jazz Bar by Ingrid Croce 
  • Brew Food by Bruce Glassman 
  • Power Entertaining by Eddie Osterland 
In January, six months after it was published, Rother’s Lost Girls was chosen as the No. 4 true-crime book by TrueCrimeZine.com.

In April, Rother also was invited for the first time to take part on a panel at the Los Angeles Times Festival of Books

“They asked me to talk about Lost Girls on a panel called Violence on the Page, and our panel was one of 10 chosen by C-SPAN to televise live,” Rother says. 

Here is a link to the podcast: http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/PanelonV

The 19th annual San Diego Book & Writing Awards will be announced Saturday, June 22, at the AMN Healthcare Building on High Bluff Drive in San Diego.

Local novelist Mark A. Clements, himself a San Diego Book Award winner, is set to be emcee.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.