Real Estate
Lake Forest City Council Debates HPC Standards Amid Modern Challenges
Navigating Tradition and Modernity: Lake Forest Grapples with Roofing Standards in Historic Homes
In a Lake Forest city council meeting held on October 2, 2023, a spotlight was cast on the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) and the challenges homeowners face regarding its roofing standards.
Cedar Roofs: A Fading Reality? Cedar shingles, a traditional roofing material favored by the HPC, are currently permitted. However, they are not only expensive to maintain but are also facing insurance issues, with many companies not ensuring them for full replacement value. Moreover, quality heartwood, essential for these shingles, is no longer easily available. This diminishes the longevity and effectiveness of the cedar roofs, pushing homeowners to seek alternatives.
Synthetics: The Modern Alternative While synthetic roofing materials offer a visually similar and more durable alternative to cedar, they often meet resistance from the HPC. One such recent appeal by a homeowner to use a synthetic roofing material was denied, sparking debates.
Find out what's happening in Lake Forest-Lake Blufffor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The 17 Standards: Time for a Revamp? The HPC abides by 17 standards, instrumental in preserving the architectural heritage of Lake Forest. However, the evolving landscape of building materials requires these standards to reflect contemporary realities. Though the HPC's goal to protect the city's historical aesthetic is commendable, a balance needs to be struck between preservation and practical modern-day solutions.
City council members understand homeowners' concerns, emphasizing the importance of modernizing while preserving history. With changing times and the rise of superior building materials, they voiced the necessity for the standards to be revisited.
Find out what's happening in Lake Forest-Lake Blufffor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The city is at a crossroads. The challenge lies in navigating the balance between Lake Forest's rich history and the evolving world of building materials. As homeowners and the city council advocate for a middle ground, the upcoming decisions of the HPC will be keenly observed.
For a closer look into the discussions and deliberations of the city council meeting, watch the video here.
