Politics & Government
Joint House, Senate Panel Revives Effort To Ban Transgender Athletes From Women's Sports
Champions of the measure said it would guarantee a level playing field for girls and women.
April 8, 2021
TOPEKA — Rep. Jerry Stogsdill recoiled at the fact a bill banning transgender girls from participating in K-12 or college women’s athletics was even being considered in Kansas.
Find out what's happening in Across Kansasfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The Fairness in Women’s Sports Act is a controversial measure requiring all school-sponsored sports teams to designate each team based on the biological sex of the team members.
Champions of the measure said it would guarantee a level playing field for girls and women. On the other hand, Opponents of the bill have argued it would establish a legal authority to further marginalize transgender people and would almost certainly be challenged in court as unconstitutional.
Find out what's happening in Across Kansasfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
“I think that this bill is literally the cherry on top of the economic sundae that is certainly melting quickly into a nasty puddle in Kansas,” said Rep. Jerry Stogsdill, D-Prairie Village. “This is morally wrong, and I think it’s prejudicial toward a large segment of our children who do identify differently.”
Sen. Molly Baumgardner, R-Louisburg, and chairwoman of the Senate Education Committee, proposed that the contents of Senate Bill 55 be replaced with that of the Fairness in Women’s Sports Act. Republican legislators from the House K-12 Education Budget Committee agreed to the proposal.
The act passed the Senate 24-10 along party lines in March but was not heard in the House. The Democratic legislators from both chambers on the conference committee opposed the bill.
On the House Floor a procedural vote to agree to disagree passed 75-42. This means only two of three members from each chamber of the conference committee must agree to the measure.
“As a mother of three daughters and one son, I want my daughters to be able to fairly compete,” said Rep. Kristey Williams, R-Augusta, in accepting the Senate proposal. “I must support our girls.”
If the act is violated, individuals and organizations may file a civil suit and seek damages or other relief.
Athletic associations, government entities and licensing organizations would be prohibited from entertaining a complaint or opening an investigation against any public education institution upholding these separate teams.
Rep. Cindy Neighbor, a Shawnee Democrat, noted personal experience with a transgender niece and gay son. She said this bill would only encourage bullying and ostracization of LGBT individuals
“They don’t come home because they are bullied. They’re ridiculed for their way of life,” Neighbor said. “Just because somebody is gay or transgender does not mean that they don’t have value.”
On the House floor, Rep. Susan Humphries said those against the bill don’t support fairness or Title IX.
“What I hear today is that women don’t matter and girls don’t matter,” Humphries said. “I don’t like being called hateful about this, but I think women and girls deserve a fair playing field.”
Opponent testimony on the bill came from Rep. Stephanie Byers, a Wichita Democrat and the state’s first transgender legislator, the Kansas National Education Association and Equality Kansas, among others. During the March hearing on the measure, they ntoed there are few instances of transgender athletes excelling in athletics due to physiological advantages.
Hundreds of NCAA and professional female athletes have come forward in support of the transgender community and in opposition of similar legislation, Byers said. She said transgender athletes only in the news on the rare occasions they win, not all the times they lose.
“They’re not dominating sports,” Byers said. “If we follow the logic all the way through about a biological advantage, then anybody who is taller than average should not be playing basketball. Anybody who’s arms are longer than average should not be swimming.”
The Attorney General’s office advised legislators that passage of the bill would likely result in a lengthy court battle over the constitutionality of the act.
In that March hearing, Rep. Barbara Ehardt — an Idaho legislator who filed the country’s first bill seeking to ban transgender girls from women’s sports — provided testimony championing the Kansas version of the legislation. Sen. Renee Erickson, R-Wichita, and a member of the conference committee, also provided testimony.
An amendment later introduced by Erickson on the Senate floor eliminated a provision that provided for physical examinations if a child’s gender is called into question. Opponents had argued this section of the bill was highly invasive and likely traumatic.
Even with the examination clause removed, Senate Minority Leaders Dinah Sykes, D-Lenexa, said the bill could have far-reaching consequences on individuals and the state.
“I think excluding women who are trans hurts all women,” Sykes said on Thursday. “It’s a bad policy that we’re trying to put in place. It will affect our economic outcomes in our state and it will hurt business.”
This story was originally published by Kansas Reflector For more stories from the Kansas Reflector visit Kansas Reflector.