Cedar Grove Man Accused Of Misusing Drug Evidence: NJAG

CEDAR GROVE, NJ — A Cedar Grove resident has been accused of misusing drug evidence while serving as a lieutenant for the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office, prosecutors announced Wednesday.

A state grand jury in Trenton indicted Kevin T. Matthew, 48, of Cedar Grove, on dozens of counts in connection with alleged evidence room “tampering,” according to the New Jersey Office of the Attorney General.

Here are the allegations against Matthew, a suspended lieutenant with the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office (BCPO):

“Between January 2019 and November 2023, Matthew allegedly signed out narcotics from BCPO’s main evidence vault that had been seized during the course of numerous BCPO narcotics investigations. The indictment contains a series of counts related to nine narcotics cases where Matthew is charged with removing and tampering with seized evidence. In each of those nine cases, Matthew is alleged to have withdrawn narcotics evidence from the vault in amounts consistent with an intent to distribute those substances.”

State prosecutors added:

“The investigation revealed that Matthew was a member of the BCPO’s Special Victims Unit, not the BCPO’s dedicated narcotics unit. Because of his official position, however, Matthew had access to law enforcement databases that contained information about narcotics cases and items of evidence, including seized illegal drugs. He allegedly searched for drug cases in those databases and, as alleged in the indictment, he periodically requested items of evidence containing narcotics held by the BCPO in matters in which he had no investigative or official role.”

According to the indictment, Matthew periodically signed out and physically removed narcotics evidence that contained cocaine, heroin, or fentanyl and that had been previously tested by the New Jersey State Police (NJSP) Laboratory for purposes that included the use of that evidence in court.

The attorney general’s office continued:

• “It is alleged that Matthew signed out items of narcotics evidence on various dates between January 2019 and November 2023, even though he lacked any authorized purpose to access that narcotics evidence as part of his job duties.”
• “According to the indictment, Matthew repeatedly returned narcotics evidence with differences in composition, weight, and/or packaging than originally documented by the NJSP Laboratory.”
• “It is further alleged that the lieutenant’s conduct has impaired the evidentiary chain of custody and the items’ reliability as evidence in criminal prosecutions.”
• “A review of the defendant’s bank records revealed that during the approximate time period when some of the evidence was being improperly removed from the vault, there was allegedly a series of cash deposits at various financial institutions, spread out across diverse dates. The indictment states that the defendant periodically made multiple cash deposits of U.S. currency totaling approximately $600,000 into accounts he controlled — deposits that are not derived from or traceable to his salary and compensation as a sworn law enforcement officer.”
• As alleged, the pattern of deposits indicates an intention to avoid banks’ federal requirement to report cash transactions in excess of $10,000 aggregated daily, the attorney general’s office said.

The indictment alleges Matthew failed to report or disclose any of the deposits as income to government agencies so that local, state or federal taxes could be collected, state prosecutors added.

The indictment charges a total of 50 counts, including Financial Facilitation of Criminal Activity (1st degree), Possession with Intent to Distribute a Controlled Dangerous Substance (1st and 2nd degree), Pattern of Official Misconduct (2nd degree), Official Misconduct (2nd degree), Possession of a Controlled Dangerous Substance (3rd degree), Tampering with Public Records or Information (3rd degree), Tampering with Physical Evidence (4th degree), Filing a Fraudulent Tax Return in 2022 and 2023 (two separate counts, 3rd degree), Structuring one or more transactions with the purpose of evading a transaction reporting requirement (3rd degree).

The attorney general’s office thanked the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office for its assistance during the investigation.

Send local news tips and correction requests to eric.kiefer@patch.com. Find out how to post announcements or events to your local Patch site.