Community Corner

HOLIDAY POLL: Is it Filling, Stuffing or Dressing?

The editor of Nazareth Patch sticks by "filling." What about you?

I grew up in a Pennsylvania Dutch household, so "filling" was the accepted way of referring to the Thanksgiving and Christmas dinner staple.

I was also a waitress for nine years at a somewhat Pennsylvania Dutch restaurant -- Hartman's Family Restaurant (I'm still mourning the death of the homemade ice cream) in Belfast. I still remember the first time a customer requested "dressing" as one of the sides.

"Um... what kind of dressing?" I wondered out loud. "You haven't asked for a salad... uh... so, dressing?"

Find out what's happening in Nazarethfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

I truly thought the person really liked salad dressing. Luckily, the customer was polite and pointed to the word "filling" on the menu. Oy...

For this poll I did a little research on the topic of filling vs. stuffing vs. dressing -- I didn't learn much. This, apparently, is a very debatable topic.

Find out what's happening in Nazarethfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

What I kind of learned:

  • "Filling" is used by the hardcore Pennsylvania Dutch.
  • "Stuffing" is used because, well, you stuff the turkey before putting it in the oven. Logical.
  • "Dressing" is used regardless of how the cook prepares the side dish. I'm still lost on this one.

So, what do you think? Make sure to take the poll below -- and feel free to explain the meaning of "dressing" in the comments section!

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

More from Nazareth