These 11 Arizona Billionaires Could Pay 20 Percent More

ARIZONA — Tempe Billionaire Ernest Garcia II, the largest shareholder in Carvana, and other wealthy Arizona residents could pay 20 percent more in taxes under a “Billionaire Minimum Tax” proposed in President Joe Biden’s fiscal year 2023 budget proposal.

The Biden administration is asking Congress to approve the proposal, part of its efforts to reduce the federal deficit over the next decade while at the same time funding new spending. The proposed tax on the ultra-wealthy would affect fewer than 1 percent of Americans, but “eliminates the inefficient sheltering of income for decades or generations,” the White House said Monday at a news conference.

Under the proposal, households worth more than $100 million would pay at least 20 percent in taxes on both income and “unrealized gains,” or the increase in an unsold investment’s value. Many wealthy people hold onto these investments for decades, meaning they’re never taxed, the administration said.

The tax would apply only to the top one-hundredth of 1 percent of Americans, Biden said at a news conference, but would raise “$360 billion that can be used to lower costs for families and cut the deficit.”

Among those likely affected would be the following Arizona residents with a place on the Forbes’ Real-Time Billionaires ranking:

• Ernest Garcia, II, the largest shareholder in Carvana, whose net worth was $9.8 billions as of the close of business Monday;
• Mark Shoen, partial owner of the parent company of U-Haul, whose net worth was $4.9 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• E. Joe Shoen, president and chairman of U-Haul's parent company, whose net worth was $4.2 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Ernest Garcia, III, founder and CEO of Carvana, whose net worth was $3.9 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Arturo Moreno, billboard advertiser and owner of the Los Angeles Angels, whose net worth was $3.6 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Bob Parsons, founder of GoDaddy, whose net worth was $3.4 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• George Kurtz, cofounder and CEO of CrowdStrike, whose net worth was $3.3 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Stewart Horejsi and family, investor in Berkshire Hathaway, whose net worth was $3.1 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Bennett Dorrance, grandson of the inventor of condensed soup and owner of 15 percent of Campbell, whose net worth was $2.9 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Peter Sperling, former chairman of the Apollo Education Group, which ran the University of Phoenix, whose net worth was $1.6 billion as of the close of business Monday;
• Jerry Moyes and family, cofounder of Swift Transportation, whose net worth was $1.5 billion as of the close of business Monday;

All of Arizona's billionaires listed by Forbes live in the Phoenix metro area.

“Now, I’m a capitalist, but … if you make a billion bucks, great,” Biden said. “Just pay your fair share. Pay a little bit.

“A firefighter and a teacher pay more than double — double the tax rate that a billionaire pays. That’s not right. That’s not fair.”

The proposed policy is “extremely nuanced,” according to an Associated Press explainer. It would allow wealthy households to spread some payments of their unrealized gains over nine years, and for five years on new income going forward. In effect, the AP explained, the payments are a prepayment on tax obligations they will owe when the investments are sold.

The proposal could be met with resistance by moderate Democrats, including Sens. Joe Manchin of West Virginia and Krysten Sinema of Arizona, but it gives Democrats a talking point as inflation reaches a 40-year high. At the same time, for Republicans who oppose it, it creates a political liability of appearing to side with multibillionaires.

Last year, ProPublica published a bombshell report based on unreleased IRS files that showed multibillionaires Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg and Rupert Murdoch paid very little or sometimes nothing at all in income taxes.

The Associated Press contributed reporting.