Simsbury Election Results 2025: Vote Totals For Every Race

SIMSBURY, CT — The votes have all been counted in Simsbury, and here are the totals for each candidate.

The preliminary vote totals are courtesy of the Connecticut Secretary of the State's Office. Bold denotes winners.

Bold denotes winners.

First Selectman (Vote for one, with losing hopefuls also up for selectmen posts)

Democrat: Wendy Mackstutis — 4,076

Republican: Heather Goetz — 3,041

Petitioning Candidate: Eric Wellman — 1,294

Incumbent Democratic First Selectman Mackstutis wins another term in office.

Board of Selectmen (Vote for up to three, with five total elected)

Democrat:

Curtis Looney — 4,804

Diana Yeisley — 4,884

Steven Antonio — 5,067

Republican:

Kevin Beal — 3,104

Edward Matteo — 3,060

Mike Paine — 3,456

The Democrats keep a 4-2 edge on the Simsbury Board of Selectmen.

Board of Finance (Vote for up to two)

Democrat:

Regina K. Pynn — 4,865

Lalitha Shivaswamy — 4,852

Republican:

Spencer Mullen — 3,260

Angel Goldman — 3,165

Board of Education (Vote for up to two, with four elected)

Democrat:

Tara Donahue Willerup — 5,230

Stephen O'Brien — 4,874

Republican:

Silvia Goldman — 2,972

Brian Watson — 3,110

Board of Assessment Appeals (Vote for one)

Republican: Scott Barnett — 4,831

Planning Commission (Vote for up to three)

Democrat:

Nicholas Criscitelli — 4,942

Marcus Furze — 4,779

Republican:

Scott Brickey — 3,327

Sean Brittell — 3,342

Julie Eaton — 4,029

Planning Commission — Two-Year Vacancy (Vote for one)

Republican: Paul Sullivan Sr. — 4,741

Zoning Commission (Vote for up to three, with three elected)

Democrat:

Tony Braz — 4,929

Dagny Griswold — 4,808

Republican:

Leo Collins Jr. — 3,286

Jackie Battos — 3,889

Brad Mead — 3,591

Zoning Commission Alternates — Two-Year Vacancy (Vote for up to Two)

Democrat:

Doug McKown — 5,129

Republican:

Stacie Espeso — 3,638

Dusty Shimkus — 3,288

Zoning Board of Appeals (Vote for up to three)

Democrat:

Ram Kaza — 4,698

Margaret Rudin — 4,962

Republican:

Ken Williams — 3,278

Ellen Gilbert — 3,629

Leo Cain Jr. — 3,338

Zoning Board of Appeals — Two-Year Vacancy (Vote for one)

Democrat: Jonathan Yeisley — 4,849

Republican Trevor Brittell — 3,216

Zoning Board of Appeal Alternate — Two-Year Vacancy (Vote for up to three)

Democrat:

John Merz — 4,765

Amy McLean Salls — 4,944

Republican:

Kelly Kearney — 3,533

Andrew Droney — 3,067

Tim Walczak — 3,419

Library Board of Trustees (Vote for up to three)

Democrat:

Don Heymann — 5,147

Republican:

Anne Erickson — 3,744

Susan Ray — 3,912

Jennifer Pringle — 3,699

Library Board of Trustees — Four-Year Vacancy (Vote for one)

Democrat: Heather Czuchta — 5,087

Republican: Ruth Scroggins — 2,998

From Nov. 3: 'Simsbury Election 2025 Voter Guide: Meet The Candidates'