Environmental Concerns Postpone Soccer Turf Work

The entrance is chained, and the "no trespassing" signs are in place.

A  soccer field that looks more like a large, exposed bed of dirt was awaiting fumigation for a nematode infestation, set for Friday.

The fumigation, part of a $57,000 city field renovation and turf replacement project, was called to an immediate halt Thursday afternoon after at least one neighbor raised environmental concerns over the use of a common soil fumigant.

"We want to make the correct decision for all involved, for the environment and for the 350 kids who play out there," Lanie Sheets, a parks and recreation official, said late Thursday.

Sports Turf One of Boyton Beach is renovating field No. 1, which, according to Sheets, has an "extremely high infestation."

Nematodes are microscopic worms that eat away at plant roots. Over time, an infestation can cause a playing surface to become uneven, increasing the risk of injury, Sheets explained. She said if the new turf is installed before the infestation is under control, the nematodes would wreak havoc on the new Bermuda sod.

"That chemical, that is one of the nastiest chemicals. ... If they think they can put a tarp over that and gas won't get out, they're crazy," 15-year resident Melissa Cassidy said. Her home is adjacent to the field. She said she experienced health complications many years earlier because of similar field treatments.

Sheets said the city staff consulted with several extension offices, professionals and scientists, and found field fumigation to be the most viable and effective solution. 

Cassidy, however, pointed officials to natural alternatives, such as a mustard and pepper extract fumigant and insecticidal soaps. Most of the companies producing natural fumigants are small and lack the funding to push for scientific studies, Cassidy said. She said the best way to manage nematodes is to "develop a healthy ecosystem," which can't happen if pesticides are used. 

For now, Cassidy is pleased with the city's decision to take a closer look at the options. She hopes they will consult the Environmental Quality Committee.

"How it proceeds from here, I don't know," Sheets said. 

The new turf will need at least two months to take hold, Sheets said. The Dunedin Stirling Soccer Club is in a brief downtime between seasons.

"We want to have some time to make sure we're making the best decision," Sheets said.