Cato Institute: 'Paving Over Debate: The ROAD to Housing Act’s Empty Promises' Fix or Flush It

Last week the Norbert Michel and Jerome Famularo for the Cato Institute wrote: "...instead of openly negotiating with members of the House of Representatives" Senators Tim Scott (SC-R) and Elizabeth Warren (MA-D) "...passed the ROAD Act as an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year 2026. Members of Congress could have openly debated these issues for months, but instead the senators decided to pressure the House by shoving the ROAD Act into a 3,100-page bill that funds the Department of Defense." While phrased differently than months of reporting by this writer for this Patch, MHProNews, and MHLivingNews that confirms the point raised that the bill - unless properly amended - will not fix the affordable housing crisis.

More on that in Part II. First up in Part I is the Cato take on the so-called Renewing Opportunity in the American Dream to Housing Act of 2025 (the ROAD to Housing Act).

Part I

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

https://www.cato.org/blog/pavi...

November 18, 2025 4:48PM
Paving Over Debate: The ROAD Act’s Quiet Passage and Its Empty Promises

By Norbert Michel and Jerome Famularo

In September 2024, Senator Tim Scott (R‑SC) introduced a 50-page bill called the Renewing Opportunity in the American Dream to Housing Act of 2025 (the ROAD to Housing Act). In 2025, as chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, he reintroduced the bill after adding 266 pages of policies that he negotiated with his Senate colleagues.

Then, instead of openly negotiating with members of the House of Representatives, Senator Scott and his colleagues passed the ROAD Act as an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year 2026. Members of Congress could have openly debated these issues for months, but instead the senators decided to pressure the House by shoving the ROAD Act into a 3,100-page bill that funds the Department of Defense.

To top things off, many pieces of the ROAD Act continue the (bad) status quo in federal housing policy, and some provisions open the door to federal meddling in state and local housing policy decisions. As we explain in our forthcoming briefing paper, the ROAD Act claims to make housing more affordable, but it’s difficult to see how it could have much of a positive impact.

Among other things, the bill makes minor changes to several Veterans Affairs programs, requires additional oversight of multiple federal regulators, and requires multiple studies. It also expands eligibility for federal grants that have existed for decades and even includes new grants to apply for grants.

Here are just a few examples of what the ROAD Act accomplishes.

• Broadens the criteria under which the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) can award grants to HUD-approved (public and private) organizations that provide homeownership and rental counseling, something that HUD has been able to do since the 1960s.
• Increases the maximum percentage that banks can invest in low- or moderate-income communities from 15 percent of their capital stock and 15 percent of their surplus to 20 percent (of each category). The threshold was set at 10 percent in 1992.
• Allows HUD to give “additional weight” to competitive grant applicants “located in, or that primarily serve” a community designated as an Opportunity Zone, a designation created in 2017. From the time these zones were created, HUD was able to award grants for projects in Opportunity Zones.

With very few exceptions, there’s nothing new here, so there’s no reason to expect results any different than those from the previous 50-plus years of federal housing policy. If Chairman Scott and his Senate colleagues want to make housing more affordable, there are countless federal policies that have distorted housing markets for decades, all of which could be eliminated or improved upon.

At the very least, Americans deserve an open debate on these policies. Instead, their senators have decided to hide these policies in a proverbial legislative haystack and all but ignore what members of the House have to say. Hopefully, Congress decides to take these policies out of the NDAA and gets to work on housing policy that will actually improve housing markets.

Part II

Earliert this week, MHProNews reached out to bipartisan lawmakers involved in the NDAA/Road to Housing Act conference commitee.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

Earlier today, MHProNews reported on various flaws exposed by this writer as well as multiple independent artificial intelligence (AI) facts-evidence-analysis (FEA) checks of the claims of the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI).

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

https://www.housingwire.com/ar...

An MHI board member, Sam Landy, recently essentially exposed MHI's failure to properly amend the ROAD Act.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

Where this writer differs on Cato's take is that this should be boiled down to a simple call for Congress to "fix or flush" the ROAD bill from the NDAA.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

The Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR) said weeks ago what was necessary for the ROAD Act to actually improve and over time end the affordable housing crisis.

https://manufacturedhousingass...

Other topics follow.

“Where Money Means More?”—Thrivent’s Tagline Meets Affordable Housing and Vexing Investment Reality Check

What happens when a financial giant with Christian roots launches a feel-good ad campaign—but is silent on questions about its investments?

Paul Steinhauser: 'Election reflection: 'Democrats flipped script' on affordability in ballot box showdown'

"Idiotic to overreact to a couple of elections in blue states." Seriously? What Steinhauser didn't say.

The State That Will Spend 28 TIMES MORE on Health Care for Illegals Than on Law Enforcement!

May not be Illegal But 'An Abuse of the Intent of the Policy'

‘Mind Your Own Business!’ ‘Do Not Be Fearful!’ About 'the End Times.' Evil Rich-Powerful Warned

‘Only the Wicked, Proud and Arrogant need be Afraid of What is Coming.’ Rev. Akalue's Glorious and Cautionary Biblical Justice.

The "Soft 2nd ‘Civil War’ in U.S."

Also: "The Long Shadow of Billionaire Warren Buffett over the Affordable Housing Crisis and the Manufactured Housing Industry"

The Time has Come for Action Over Posturing and Words SNAP, MHARR and Housing Crisis House-Senate Must Act

House-Senate Called to Fix SNAP Funding, Get Fed Employees Paid-MHARR Calls on Congress-Trump Admin and MHI to Fix ROAD to Housing Act

AEI’s Tobias Peter Says: ‘The ROAD to Housing Act is a Dead End for Republicans’

Apparent Hits and Misses from Tobias Peter's Potent Slam of ‘The ROAD to Housing Act'

Bill Gates Surprising Shift on Climate Change

What Bill Gates Did and Did Not Say and What Might have Motivated the Centi-Billionaires's Shift on Climate?

Figuring out what is true and what is corporate, political, or nonprofit bluster or bias

Andrew Cuomo, Zohran Mamdani, and Curtis Sliwa. How to best use AI systems to get reliable insights. A step-by-step Q&A example.

Sam Landy's documented remarks are important for understanding the affordable housing crisis

UMH Properties CEO Landy's remarks "a thunderclap" revealing, important for understanding MHARR, MHI, NAHB, NAR, FHFA Dir. Bill Pulte & more

There are no perfect people walking the Earth today. There are no perfect organizations either.

Why the lack of perfection among mere humans matters and why a lack of perfect orgs can help inform and guide prudent choices.

'The premiums for ObamaCare are up 60% since 2010 when that bill was enacted' - Speaker Mike Johnson

'Republicans united in ending shutdown, responsibly reining in federal spendin-getting federal govt working for Americans'-Rep Andy Harris

Sunday Readings and a Surge in Religious Worship Attendance?

Sunday Scripture Readings per USCCB plus Anecdotal Evidence of increasing Practice of Faith since Charlie Kirk’s Murder.

“Deception, Misdirection, and Market Power: Manufactured Housing’s Hidden Crisis”

Why Unless Amended ROAD to Housing Act 2025 Is Detour from Real Reform

Do YOU Believe in Miracles? What would you say about evidence of a modern miracle witnessed by 70,000 people?

There are all kinds of miracles, some arguably real, others that are either imagined or fake. This miracle was reported in the newspapers.

Faith vs. Fortune: Is Your Christian Financial Advisory Funding Firm Accused of Harming Homeownership?

Exposé questions Thrivent investments in manufactured housing firms including Champion Homes (SKY) Berkshire Hathaway (BRK) moral issues

Mario Enzler on his "hero" John Paul II "The Man, the Pope, the Saint"

Scriptural verses often cited for invoking intercessory prayers of saints include Revelation 5:8, Rev. 8:3-4 and Ephesians 6:18

‘Supreme Court asked to end Realtors’ ‘optional’ rules’-Possible Multi-Billion Dollar Case and SCOTUS

'Seismic Changes' Could help - or harm FSBOs. 'Could set precedent for challenging similar gatekeeping' in other parts of housing industry

Trailer Houses to Mobile Homes to Manufactured Homes 'Industry Mired-Regulatory Neglect-Market Manipulation'

Investors. Affordable Housing Advocates. Researchers. Attorneys, Officials & AGs. Beyond Esther Sullivan. 16th MHProNews Anniversary Exposé

Your Voice Matters. Future of Housing-Taxes-Your Home May Depend on it. Call or message Congressional Rep

NAR. MHI. MHARR. Those trade groups have sounded off on this bill. Some argue the bill will harm, not help, unless changed.

‘Follow the Money’ ‘Cui Bono’ Paltering Posturing and Illusory Truth

Understanding Lack of Affordable Housing-Tips for Those Who Know Concepts of Masking Truth About Corruption–HUD Scott Turner, Fed Officials

Understanding Affordable Housing Crisis-ChatGPT and other AI on MHI-MHARR-Crisis Case Study

FEA Journalism "rare," "unique," and "transparent," telling readers, "don't just trust us, check us." ChatGPT-Gemini-Copilot-Grok-Case Study

'People over Machines' Chris Woodward on "U.S. Sen. Mark Kelly Presents 'AI for America' Roadmap"

Known as "AI for America" says Steps Must be Taken so Artificial Intelligence Revolution “Ensure this Technology" "Benefit to All"

More Americans Say They're Conservative Than Other Groups As America Reaches a Turning Point

Manzanita Miller 'in wake of Charlie Kirk’s death, nearly two-thirds of the nation is rejecting the senseless ideology of radical left'

MHARR Calls on President Trump to Enforce Existing Federal Laws to Solve Affordable Housing Crisis

Experts say solving affordable housing crisis could boost economy $2 Trillion annually. Per Gemini, that's over $15,000 per U.S. household.

Unpacking Today's Scripture Readings-Reality of Heaven and Hell-Who Wants Eternal Joy?

Rev Akalue Provides Commentary on Bible Readings. Keen Insights into true Wealth and Poverty, Sorrow or Joy

'Did God really say it?' Lutheran Church announces which Bible verses it condemns

'The premiums for ObamaCare are up 60% since 2010 when that bill was enacted' - Speaker Mike Johnson

'Republicans united in ending shutdown, responsibly reining in federal spendin-getting federal govt working for Americans'-Rep Andy Harris

‘Follow the Money’ ‘Cui Bono’ Paltering Posturing and Illusory Truth

Understanding Lack of Affordable Housing-Tips for Those Who Know Concepts of Masking Truth About Corruption–HUD Scott Turner, Fed Officials

More Americans Say They're Conservative Than Other Groups As America Reaches a Turning Point

Manzanita Miller 'in wake of Charlie Kirk’s death, nearly two-thirds of the nation is rejecting the senseless ideology of radical left'

‘Charlie Kirk Warned Bad Stuff Happens When People Stop Talking-Let’s Keep Talking America’

Perhaps more than ever, left and right need to be willing to listen-read-think about areas of common ground-common sense & mutual respect.

Survey Finds Married Women with Children Happier than Those Who Focus on Career-See Survey Results

'Being married is most important differentiator of happiness in America, with married people 30 percentage points happier than unmarried'

Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR) Submits Amendments to Address Key Bottlenecks

MHARR Comments Reveal Key Misses by Manufactured Housing Institute, other affordable housing advocates in ROAD to Housing 2025 Bill.

Pew Research: 'U.S. Immigrant Population Declines for First Time in Nearly 60 Years'

The polling is interesting. But how does immigration policy, particularly illegal immigration, impact the lives of you and those you love?

'I am not right' Catholic Church/School shooter identified as anti-Trump transgender

'Unfortunately due to my depression anger and twisted mind I want to fulfill in a final act that has been in the back of my head for years'

Concerns Over John and Nisha Whitehead, Rutherford.org, Recent Anti-Trump Rants Explored

"The U.S. Government Is Waging Psychological War on Its Citizens: Inside the Deep State’s PsyOps Machine" See What the Whiteheads said

Manufactured Housing “Insiders” Praised-Get 'Awards' While Residents File Lawsuits: A Tale of Two Reports

Yes! Communities Steve Schaub RV-MH Hall of Fame 'Induction'-Frank Rolfe-Sun CEO Gary Shiffman Reveal Manufactured Housing Institute Leaders

'Shut it Down!' FBI were Investigating 19 Clinton Foundation bank accounts before DOJ put kibosh on probe.

Newly declassified FBI docs reveal they were investigating at least 19 Clinton Foundation bank accounts for 'campaign finance fraud'

Autumn Dorsey: "We Should Not Be Digital Slaves" 'Reality is not Destiny.' The FTC v. Meta case

'Meta collects your browsing history, your financial information, and even your sensitive health data' 'Meta’s greed transformed your data'

Rep. Eric Burlison-'This is not a conspiracy theory. These are documented facts—confirmed by the CIA itself.'

Congressman Eric Burlison - 'Congress Must Hold the CIA Accountable in the Wake of Recent JFK Assassination Revelations'

'TOTAL Scam' - Gov. Ron DeSantis calls H-1B Visa Program 'Terrible Policy'

Gov. Ron DeSantis (FL-R) Slams Democrats and Republicans on H-1B Visa Program

ROAD to Housing 2025 WON'T Work-How Liberals & Conservatives Can Meet to Solve the Affordable Housing Crisis

People of Faith, Take Note. Applying the Drew Mariani Formula – 'I don’t follow the donkey. I don’t follow the elephant. I follow the Lamb.'

Defector and Former KGB agent Yuri Alexandrovich Bezmenov Explained How U.S. Would Be Toppled by Enemies

Nikita Khrushchev: 'We can’t expect Americans to jump from Capitalism to Communism but can get Leaders to Accept Small Doses of Socialism.'IRS Complaint Filed Against Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI)-Is Accountability Finally Coming?Evidence-Backed Complaint Submitted to Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Requesting Investigation into the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI)

GIGO-Important for Understanding Computers, Search Results, AI, plus Human Understanding and Behavior too

'Garbage In, Garbage out' (GIGO) is Principle in Computer Programming and Mathematics Quality of Output is Directly Linked to Quality Input

Could a Letter You Received Months or Years Ago Now Earn You a BIG DOJ Whistleblower Reward?

Living on leased land in 'mobile home park' or manufactured home community? Get letter from "predatory" biz? Retailer who got a 21st Letter?

The Amazing Relevance and Importance of the Dead Sea Scrolls (DSS) to our World

Discover an Insightful Hybrid Blend into Biblical Truth, Evidence for the Existence of God and Important Topics like Free Will

Countdown to 250 – Critiquing Leftist and Rightwing Views Yields Path Forward for All–Peter Berkowitz via RCP

'Rescuing The Declaration From Left- And Right-Wing Polemics' - Includes a Peek into Making AI Better in the Context of Improving America

Robert Knight-'Pastors should be more involved in politics, not less' - Claims and Counterclaims

Knight-'They should speak out more forcefully against politicians who enact evil policies'

Even AI Admits Artificial Intelligence Poses ‘Dystopian’ Risk to Humanity; Truth-Faith-Reason Needed in U.S.

Independence Day is a Reminder that Freedom Isn't Free and There are Roles that Reason, Faith, and History All Play in Solving Modern Woes

About 2/3rds of Democats Want New Democratic Party Leadership and Millions Favor Trump's No Nukes for Iran

Miller: 'Congressional Democrats have been unable to leverage climate of political uncertainty for their benefit and are falling behind.'

Mobile Home Manufacturers Association vs. Manufactured Housing Institute - Historic Peek at Parks-Production

'Someone can be wrong without lying. But if someone keeps saying or doing the same misleading things knowing they are wrong, they are lying'

‘$500 Million Dollars’ in ‘Prime Washington D.C. Real Estate is FOR SALE’ – Underused Federal Buildings

Trump Administration is seeking to reduce unnecessary costs identified by DOGE, plus an Update on the so-called POTUS Trump-Elon Musk Fued.

Hollis-Western Society will be Destroyed Without a Commitment to Truth

'Real education starts with a belief in objective truth and commitment to finding and promoting it. Western society will end without it.'

Emanuel-'Dem Party Weak and Woke' Amid Rumors Rahm wants White House

'Toxic' said former Obama-Biden era Chief of Staff and Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel slams Dems 'American Dream has Become Unaffordardable'

Accused of Hypocrisy-Fair?

Senator Bernie Sanders himself said that Democrats drifted from being the party of the working man to embracing financial elites-the latest.

Grocery Prices See Biggest Drop in 5 Years as Trump Policies Take Hold

DCNF: "Grocery prices fell more in April than they have since 2020, driven by egg prices that saw their biggest drop in more than 40 years."

Artificial Intelligence and Human Expert-AI Boosted Hybrid Journalism

The U.S. Affordable Housing Crisis is often Misunderstood. To Clarify Thorny Issues, Human Expertise & AI Boosted Fact Checks of Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) and the Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR).

Hanne Nabintu Herland-Much Ado About History

What Marxist Philosophers did to the West, as Explained by Author and Historian Hanne Nabintu Herland - Why Understanding History Matters

Top Florida Senate Democrat Quits: 'Dem Party in Florida Is Dead'

ActBlue - Two Sides of a Looming U.S. Democrats vs. Republicans Drama

American Dream of Homeownership is Slipping Away-Association Spotlight

Congressional Lawmakers "Monopoly Busters Caucus" to Fight High Costs

Lakeland Study Test Frank Rolfe Claim "Mobile Homes" Lower Prop Values

Hybrid Expert Human Study Combined with Multiple AI Powered Fact Checks plus 3rd Party Research Expose Disputed Claims in Critical Reporting

Is Decline in Christianity in U.S. Over? Pew Research Suggests It Is

Numbers of Those Praying and Attending Religious Services or Mass Have Stabilized According to Recent Findings Including a Big New Pew Study

Dems Fretting Over Billionaires Are on Billionaire Dole for Years

Audrey Streb-for DCNF and via Daily Signal: Democratic Officials that Criticized Wealthy Despite Taking Funding from Billionaires (Ouch!)

THE Reality Check-All of Us Have Been Manipulated & Lied to-E. Nickson

Employees! It is ‘Not Free Market Capitalism It’s Corporate Feudalism’

Federal Racket-Follow the Money-Tammany Hall 2.0 and Big U.S. Media

> Virginia Bishop for ‘Well-Regulated Borders’ Amid VP J.D. Vance Rumble

> Why do Liars Lie? Why do those Engaged in Paltering and Spin Palter?

> Orlando RE Agent Smith-Younger Adults Will Need $8500 Monthly for Rent

> Christian Leaders-Signs of 4th 'Great Awakening' Millions go to Jesus

> Attorney John Morgan - Democrat Megadonor on Kamala Harris Campaign

> USA Today - David Plouffe and Dem Advisers on Kamala Harris Revelation

> The Creepy Line-Peter Schweizer-Dr. Jordan Peterson-Dr. Robert Epstein

> Secret State Miniseries - Fictional TV Series Shed Light on Reality

> Top 10 States for Homelessness & Top Cities for Crime=Shocking Lessons

> Blankley-Goodbye American Dream? Only 10% Polled Can Buy a House; But

> Frank Rolfe-Special Interests ‘Don’t Want to Solve Affordable Housing'

> TARK-‘I’m a Teen and Know the Solution to Affordable Housing Crisis’

---> Renting? Rent too High? Odds Are DOJ Suit vs RealPage Matters to You

> New-Certified “Half Price Homes” - Affordable Housing Solution Redux

---

> Solution: “Would-Be Homebuyers Need 80% More Income Than 4 Years Ago”

L. A. “Tony” Kovach is a publisher who has earned multiple awards in history. He and his family live in a manufactured home on private property in Winter Haven, FL. He is the co-founder of Manufactured Home Living News.com (MHLivingNews.com) and Manufactured Home Pro News.com (MHProNews.com), trade publications serving segments of the manufactured home industry. Having worked in several segments of the manufactured home industry for over 3 decades, Kovach is a widely acknowledged and often praised expert on manufactured housing.

According to scores of industry pros and three different AI fact-checks, Kovach is the most prolific, most rigorous, most factually accurate-document rich research-reporter on manufactured housing industry issues in the 21st century. But I do get fat finger typos. Please pardon those when you find them. ###

| Share /