Selena Gomez’s Most Iconic OMITB S05 Outfits (Ranked by Fans)

Season five of Only Murders in the Building has brought gripping plot twists, sharper dialogue, and a fresh wave of wardrobe moments from Selena Gomez as Mabel Mora. But this season, her fashion has done more than just complement the story it’s created its own headlines. Fans have taken to social media to share their favorite looks, compare past seasons, and even recreate her iconic pieces.

In this fan-voted ranking, we explore the most talked-about and stylish OMITB S05 Selena Gomez outfits, complete with fashion commentary and why each one stood out.

1. The Sleeveless Cream Mini Dress and Structured Trench

At the top of nearly every fan poll is Mabel’s refined cream mini dress paired with a long, neutral-toned trench. This look defined the promotional rollout for the season and quickly became symbolic of her character’s self-assurance and independence.

Why it ranked #1:
The clean silhouette and elevated color palette reflected Mabel’s emotional clarity. Fans loved the mix of softness and power and the internet couldn’t get enough of the contrast between the minimal dress and the bold outerwear.

2. The Burgundy Leather Jacket Moment

Mabel’s rich burgundy leather jacket worn during a key investigation scene sparked instant fan appreciation. It was structured, cinematic, and slightly mysterious a perfect visual echo of the show’s mood.

Fan reactions:
Social threads lit up with questions about where to find a similar jacket. Many praised the way it brought a retro edge without feeling costume-like. As one commenter said, “This jacket is Mabel bold, dramatic, and unpredictable.”

3. Cozy Oversized Hoodie and Beanie Combo

A flashback episode gave us a nostalgic taste of Mabel’s old-school vibe with her signature oversized hoodie and knit beanie both updated in softer, washed tones.

Why fans loved it:
This outfit reminded long-time viewers of her vulnerable early days while still feeling updated. The hoodie sparked a conversation about comfort-core fashion and how OMITB S05 Selena Gomez outfits still honor character continuity.

4. The Longline Gray Coat and Turtleneck Layering

One of the most stylish cold-weather looks this season, Mabel’s tailored gray coat worn over a fitted black turtleneck brought elegance and precision to the screen. It was practical for sleuthing and yet fashionably understated.

Community poll response:
This look ranked high for its everyday appeal. “I would wear this to work or dinner,” wrote one fan. “It’s classy, effortless, and very New York.”

5. Velvet Maroon Blazer with Gold Hoop Earrings

This blazer moment was all about contrast the luxe fabric against her cool, no-nonsense vibe. The gold hoops added an edge, showing how even subtle accessories in OMITB S05 Selena Gomez outfits were thoughtfully placed.

Fashion takeaway:
This was the outfit that made fashion fans realize: Mabel’s wardrobe has officially matured. Gone are the purely functional pieces. Every item now tells a story.

6. Patterned Knit Sweater with Vintage Denim

Not every fan-favorite was polished or dramatic. This more casual look a cozy patterned sweater worn with high-rise vintage denim brought balance to the otherwise sharp aesthetic of the season.

Why it resonated:
It brought back the approachable, artistic Mabel from earlier seasons while incorporating her now-refined layering choices. A fan put it best: “It’s the look I’d wear when I want to feel like myself but cooler.”

7. Black Structured Bomber with Dark Denim

This powerful streetwear-inspired look closed out a tense episode. The bomber jacket had subtle leather detailing and sharp lines, a modern update that many saw as a nod to crime-core and street fashion influences.

Commentary:
Though it came later in the season, fans responded with excitement. “I paused the screen just to study that jacket,” said one fashion follower. It’s now a top-searched style for fans looking to recreate the vibe of OMITB S05 Selena Gomez outfits.

What Fans Agree On: Selena's Wardrobe Is Its Own Character Now

Across Reddit threads, X polls, and Instagram reels, one thing is clear: Selena Gomez’s outfits in OMITB S05 aren't just scene dressing. They're an emotional and narrative tool. From her evolving silhouettes to bold outerwear, Mabel’s wardrobe reflects her growth from guarded loner to bold truth-seeker.

Fans also note how wearable the looks are. Whether it’s a bomber jacket, a cotton trench, or a hoodie layered under a wool coat, these pieces are stylish without feeling inaccessible. Many fans have even said they’re now shopping with “Mabel logic” searching for jackets, blazers, or trench coats that look effortlessly smart but subtly cinematic.