Why Hinsdale South Gets More Money Per Student

HINSDALE, IL – By one metric, it appears that Hinsdale South High School gets a better deal than its sister, Hinsdale Central.

But context is needed.

Last school year, Hinsdale High School District 86 spent $32,228 per student at South, considerably more than the $25,121 at Central, according to state statistics.

In its narrative to the state, the district gave the same explanation that it has for years: "By allocating our funding in an equitable manner, we are able to address the difference in the economies of scale in our buildings, and, more importantly, meet the diverse needs of our students."

During a recent finance committee meeting, school board members were told that economies of scale were the main reason for the disparity. South's enrollment is half that of Central's.

A bigger school can spread the costs of certain functions – such as administration – over a greater population. Hinsdale Central and South have the same administrative positions with similar salaries.

But for many years, Central, with its wealthier student body, has enjoyed a greater course selection, a gap that officials have downplayed.

Earlier this year, the district claimed it had nearly wiped out the disparity, but later admitted its numbers were wrong. The district has since hired a data consultant.