Reader's Choice: Celebrating St. Paddy's Day at PJ Finnegan's

Irish eyes will be smiling on Saturday at for St. Patrick's Day celebrations across the state but in the River Dell area, 100% of voters stated they prefer the Fairview Avenue location.

For over 30 years, PJ Finnegan's has embraced its roots by displaying both Irish and American flags outside its door. The interior has an inviting pub atmosphere and an extensive bar, with a choice selection of beers on tap. Finnegan's has the feeling of "where the locals meet" and an impressive display of old-time sports memorabilia covering every inch of wall space. 

"PJ Finnegan's is a great bar and restaurant for the family, friends, or business associates,"  wrote, giving Finnegan's a five-star rating. "If you’re hungry, PJ Finnegan’s is the place for you. With a menu that offers great specials that range from Crab Cakes to Stuffed Loin of pork, as well as the favorite ‘pub grub’, there’s something for everyone here. If you’re just out for a drink, you’re in the right place. With a nice collection of bottled beers, wine, spirits, as well as five beers on tap including what may be the best Guinness in Bergen County, PJ Finnegan’s is a great place to be."

Finnegan's is open seven days a week and earned a four-star rating on Yelp as well as a 95% favorable rating on Urban Spoon.

From it's classic Fish and Chips to Shepard's Pie and wide range of desserts and drinks, Finnegan's has been called the "quintessential neigborhood bar."

"Great pub food and a strong selection of Irish beers makes this a great night out," Matthew R. of River Vale wrote on Yelp. "The atmosphere is eclectic, but not forced (the decorations range from college pennants to Irish wall art, but it isn't contrived like some major chains). The snacks at the bar are semi-addictive, but the menu is standard pub food with a few Irish specialties."

"If you're looking for a great Irish Pub with a neighborhood feel, this is your place," added Meghann Robinson on Urban Spoon. "I eat there at least once a month and love it."

Next week, Patch is looking for your Favorite Grocery Store." The voting begins at 5 a.m. on Monday.