Prominent Pittsburgh Sports Figure Puts Home On Market

PITTSBURGH, PA — A lightning rod of controversy on the Pittsburgh sports scene has put his home on the market, perhaps foreshadowing an impending exit from the city.

Amid a cataclysmically disastrous start to the 2025 season, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington on Tuesday placed his Sewickley Heights home up for sale. The property is listed for sale on Zillow; Cherington's ownership of the house was confirmed on the Allegheny County real estate website.

News of the home being marketed first was reported on Oneburgh.

Cherington is asking $1.69 million for the four-bedroom, five-bathroom home. Cherington and his wife, Tyler Tumminia, purchased the property in January 2021 for $1.2 million, according to real estate records.

"Step into the timeless elegance of Hollow Hill, a 1910 Tudor Revival residence nestled on 7 acres in Sewickley Heights," the Zillow listing states.

"Adjacent to the 4th tee box of Allegheny Country Club, this storied property was once part of the historic Rea Estate, blending legacy with modern lifestyle potential. This warm and inviting home exudes understated charm. The cozy interior is highlighted by a wood-burning fireplace and a thoughtfully designed farm-style kitchen with stainless steel appliances.

"One of the standout features is the Amish-built barn. This exceptional structure with meticulous detailing provides endless possibilities for entertaining, creative endeavors or simply enjoying the serene surroundings. The acreage offers privacy and tranquility and the prime location is just minutes from Sewickley's vibrant village. Whether you're drawn by its historic allure, idyllic setting or future potential, Hollow Hill is an opportunity to own a piece of Sewickley Height's history."

Zillow says that tours of the property can be scheduled as soon as today.

Cherington's future in Pittsburgh recently has been the subject of intense speculation in Pittsburgh as the Pirates have stumbled to a horrible 14-29 record to begin the season. They are in last place in the National League Central Division.

Now in his sixth season as general manager, Cherington's teams have never finished higher than fourth in the five-team division.

Last week, Cherington fired manager Derek Shelton amid the team's terrible start.