Politics & Government
Donating To Hurricane Harvey Relief? Why People Are Rethinking Giving To Red Cross
Many are rethinking where to send their donations after a series of articles on Red Cross' spending after previous disasters.

Americans donating to Hurricane Harvey relief have a variety of organizations, both local and national, to choose from, and one of the most recognizable organization is the American Red Cross. Former President Barack Obama even tweeted to his nearly 95 million followers suggesting a donation to the Red Cross as a way to help Harvey victims.
A series of articles, however, raise questions about how much of the money donated to the Red Cross actually goes directly to relief efforts. In an interview with NPR's Alisa Chang, Red Cross executive Brad Kiserman was asked about the organization's high administrative costs, and he was unable to say how much money exactly goes to relief.
Kiserman was asked directly how much of every dollar goes to relief, and he said he did not know the answer to that. He told NPR that as of Wednesday morning the Red Cross had spent $50 million in Harvey relief, on 232 shelters for 66,000 people.
Find out what's happening in Houstonfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Asked about an NPR report that 25 percent of the money donated for Haiti after the 2010 earthquake went to internal Red Cross spending and whether that was still happening, Kiserman said it's not something he has "visibility on."
>>>You can listen to the full NPR Morning Edition interview here.
Find out what's happening in Houstonfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
In a blog post, the Red Cross explained their response effort to Hurricane Harvey.
Both NPR and ProPublica have reported on Red Cross spending, and after the latest NPR report, ProPublica explained in a series of tweets what it found about Red Cross spending after major disasters, including the organization's response to Hurricane Sandy.
1/ #Harvey has devastated Texas. In time of devastation, people give to disaster relief. And so let’s talk about the @RedCross for a second.
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
2/ You maybe saw the @BarackObama tweet telling people to give to the @RedCross. https://t.co/kdQxDf0HK6
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
3/ However, WaPo reported that folks are urging people to donate for #Harvey relief… just not to the @RedCross: https://t.co/lThhppeBZc
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
4/ Things haven’t been going too well for the charity so far: https://t.co/dNGPP424mD pic.twitter.com/sdp30U9EZC
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
5/ This is not a shock to us. Why? Let’s go through this all again:
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
6/ A few years ago, we started looking into how millions in Sandy donations were spent. They wouldn’t tell us. https://t.co/RVRXA5pykP
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
7/ We kept reporting and got here: the @redcross botched its response to Superstorm Sandy and put PR over victims. https://t.co/fCNyKoJtEI
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
8/ 8 months later, we reported that the @RedCross raised a half billion dollars for Haiti & built 6 homes. Just six. https://t.co/ed9lyYMnX9
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
9/ Then it failed in Louisiana: https://t.co/S9eM4833ss
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
10/ Then it stumbled in Mississippi: https://t.co/U5VLecJcuO
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
11/ @RedCross has also serially misled donors on how much $$ goes to disaster relief. It’s not 91 cents per dollar: https://t.co/89o26rOYmN
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
12/ A gov't investigation started looking into the charity’s disaster response/oversight. Its CEO tried to spike it: https://t.co/T3Rp8sEuD4
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
13/ Then a blistering Senate report said @RedCross CEO made false statements to Congress. https://t.co/EbRmguUssb
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
14/ Even internally, trust appears to be an issue: only 35% of employees said they trust @RedCross leadership: https://t.co/n0vhU1z8Qn
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
15/ And now #Harvey has dumped trillions of gallons of water on Houston and the @RedCross may be stumbling again: https://t.co/dNGPP424mD
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
16/ So we’re on it. But also need your help. In response to #Harvey, how’s the @RedCross doing? Have any tips? Email RedCross@propublica.org pic.twitter.com/ICsc6M2t0w
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
17/17 Finally, if you are looking to donate to disaster relief, read this first: https://t.co/Zmhzgb3tu2
— ProPublica (@ProPublica) August 30, 2017
The questions raised in both NPR and ProPublica's reporting are causing people to rethink donating to the Red Cross.
Exhibit A on why you should not donate to Red Cross. Donate locally to Hurricane Harvey Relief Efforts instead. https://t.co/AJNpAtSgB1
— Matthew A. Cherry (@MatthewACherry) September 1, 2017
My thoughts on donating to #HurricaneHarveyRelief and @RedCross in particular. Find a local charity instead. pic.twitter.com/RgX8IqUsTE
— Mr. Endo (@MrEnd0) September 1, 2017
Do not give money to the Red Cross. https://t.co/sy2v5qlyb1
— Amadi (@amaditalks) August 31, 2017
IF you're wondering why not the Red Cross, start here. https://t.co/egV3B65hwq
— ProfB (@AntheaButler) August 30, 2017
Photo: Evacuees fill up cots at the George Brown Convention Center that has been turned into a shelter run by the American Red Cross to house victims of the high water from Hurricane Harvey. Photo by Erich Schlegel/Getty Images News/Getty Images
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.