Beloved Branford Brewery Stuns With News Of Upcoming Closure

BRANFORD, CT — Thimble Island Brewing Company announced in a heartfelt message that it is closing for good on May 24.

The beloved brewery at 16 Business Park Dr. has 38,000 Facebook likes and is one of the most well-known breweries in the state. The brewery has been in operation since 2012 and its founder and CEO is Justin Gargano.

"This is one of the harder messages I’ve ever had to write. After a lot of thought (and a lot of emotion), I’ve decided to close Thimble Island Brewing Company. Our last day of service will be Saturday, May 24," the brewery announced on its Facebook page.

"Like many small businesses, we've faced some tough challenges over the past several years. Industry declines coupled with a strategic partnership that didn’t go as planned had a significant impact on our business. At the same time, I’ve been navigating some personal health challenges that made it clear I needed to pause, reset, and re-evaluate.

"This business has been such a huge part of my life — not just professionally, but personally. It’s been full of long days, proud moments, and most importantly, incredible people like you who supported it, believed in it, and helped it grow. It has been a joy and a privilege to serve this community. Thank you for your support, trust, and encouragement. Though this chapter is coming to a close, I’m looking ahead with gratitude and hope for what’s next. With gratitude, Justin."

The news was met with sadness from longtime patrons.

One person wrote on Facebook, "Justin, your heart, hustle, and hops have made a lasting mark on the shoreline—and clearly on many who have crossed paths with you. From that first tap at Sea Grass Grill to every pint after, it’s been fun watching your journey. I’m truly sorry to hear about the health challenges and tough decisions, but I admire your strength in sharing them. Wishing you good health, peace, and a fresh start full of good things. You built something pretty cool."

Another person wrote, "Best beer in the area, I've been a huge fan for years. Definitely going to be missed."