Attorneys Cite Blue Orca, Warn Sun Communities CEO Should Be in Prison

There is a well-documented affordable housing crisis in the U.S. Several research reports by sources including Harvard, Pew, HUD, CFPB, the Urban Institute, Freddie Mac, the National Association of Realtors, Niskanen Center, Minneapolis Federal Reserve, and others have said modern manufactured homes are often misunderstood and are an important part of the solution to the affordable housing crisis. Yet manufactured housing is underperforming. For thinking people, that raises the question, why is manufactured housing underperforming? A detailed report released this week by Blue Orca apparently contributed to manufactured home community operator Sun Communities (SUI) share prices to drop sharply. Several law firms cited the Blue Orca report in announcing investigations on behalf of shareholders in Sun Communities.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

While allegations by Blue Orca are focused on the investment side of Sun Communities, that doesn't mean that their research doesn't have several possible implications for affordable housing advocates. As was noted above and is detailed in the report linked here, Blue Orca's report is attributed by several law firms as having caused a slide in Sun Communities' stock value.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

According to Blue Orca: “an attorney provided a sworn statement that a Department of Homeland Security agent involved in the investigation said that the CEO “should be in prison.” This scandal, in our view, raises significant questions as to management credibility and trustworthiness as a steward of investor capital.”

MHProNews has reported several times on concerns similar to those raised by Blue Orca and attorneys that cited their research. There are arguably potential issues that Blue Orca missed, but they have also presented information that will be new to numbers of investors and perhaps public officials concerned with possible market manipulation and antitrust concerns.

Per Blue Orca: "History of Alleged Accounting Shenanigans and Reporting Failures Casts Shadow Over Current Financials. Sun Communities is no stranger to allegations of financial impropriety under its still-current CEO. The SEC settled an enforcement action against the Company, and then filed a district court lawsuit against CEO Shiffman, SUI’s then CFO, and its former Controller for hiding losses in a subsidiary and maintaining a literal “cookie jar” reserve to smooth earnings. The SEC eventually dismissed Shiffman and the former Controller from the lawsuit, but notably it settled the lawsuit against SUI’s then-CFO, requiring him to serve a two-year suspension from practicing before the SEC as an accountant (though, surprisingly, he remained with the Company in another capacity)."

Also according to Blue Orca: “Our diligence reveals that SUI’s CEO received an undisclosed $4 million loan from the family of a purportedly independent Director who has sat on the Audit Committee and chaired the Compensation Committee for close to a decade.” “Incredibly, SUI’s CEO was also embroiled in a scandal involving the falsification of his mother’s medical records to facilitate the fraudulent sale of $63 million of life insurance policies he took out on his mother’s life. Although he was not charged or formally accused of wrongdoing by law enforcement, in a sworn deposition, the physician who faked the medical records accused the CEO of personally directing the insurance fraud scheme. Further, an attorney provided a sworn statement that a Department of Homeland Security agent involved in the investigation said that the CEO “should be in prison,” per Blue Orca’s pitch that for reasons that they are short on higher profile Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) member Sun Communities (SUI)

This contributing writer for the Patch recently shared a public challenge for the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) to respond to an array of ethical and legal allegations involving scandals beyond those involving Shiffman and Sun. See the report linked below. There has been no known public response by MHI, which means they have neither confirmed nor denied the concerns raised in the report with analysis linked below.

https://patch.com/florida/lake...

Consider this Q&A with left-leaning Bing's artificial intelligence (AI) powered Copilot.

Inquiry sent by you (i.e.: this contributing writer for the Patch):

Copilot, MHProNews has published a new report based on concerns raised by several law firms that cited Blue Orca's research into Sun Communities and their CEO Gary Shiffman at this link here: https://www.manufacturedhomepr... Are you aware of any response by Sun or the Manufactured Housing Institute to that or to the post linked here? https://patch.com/florida/lake... If so, please share those linked responses. If not, do you logically

perceive these claims are based on evidence that appears to be well supported by evidence?

Copilot

Sent by Copilot:

I couldn’t find any specific responses from Sun Communities or the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) directly addressing the Blue Orca report or the concerns raised in the MHProNews article. However, here are some relevant points and sources:

1. Sun Communities: There has been significant coverage of the allegations made by Blue Orca, including claims of undisclosed loans and conflicts of interest involving CEO Gary Shiffman12. However, I did not find any direct response from Sun Communities addressing these specific allegations.
2. Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI): While I didn’t find a direct response to the specific issues raised in the MHProNews article, MHI has been active in discussing broader topics related to manufactured housing and affordability. For example, MHI has recently applauded the New Democrat Coalition’s Housing Action Plan, which emphasizes the importance of manufactured housing in affordable homeownership3. Additionally, MHI has responded to various opinion pieces and policy discussions, highlighting their stance on manufactured housing standards and affordability4.

Regarding the credibility of the claims, the Blue Orca report appears to be detailed and supported by specific allegations, such as the undisclosed $4 million loan1. However, without a direct response from Sun Communities or further independent verification, it’s challenging to fully assess the validity of these claims. It’s essential to consider multiple perspectives and await any official statements or legal outcomes that may provide more clarity.
If you have any more specific questions or need further information, feel free to ask!

Learn more

1 manufacturedhomepronews.com 2 globenewswire.com 3 manufacturedhousing.org 4 manufacturedhousing.org 5 urban.org 6 manufacturedhomepronews.com 7 seekingalpha.com 8 morningstar.com ..."

That Q&A with Copilot is captured in the screen shot below.

Note that the Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR) has been a multi-year critic of MHI's various claimed failures to effectively address enforcement of existing federal laws that due to lack of enforcement are contributing to the underperformance of the industry. For example from MHARR:

Bottlenecks Suppressing Manufactured Housing Industry Continue Unabated

A source with direct ties to MHARR has told MHProNews that no articles are posted on the MHARR website that are not first reviewed and authorized by their president and CEO, Mark Weiss, J.D. That noted, back to a follow up Q&A with Copilot related to Blue Orca and Patch related concerns.

Inquiry sent by you (i.e.: this contributing writer for the Patch):

Copilot, interesting that you should mention that MHI has responded to other items, but not to the Patch or MHProNews related ones. Regarding MHI and the New Dems, this fact-backed analysis by MHProNews stands unrefuted does it not? https://www.manufacturedhomepr... And MHI has oddly failed to address the apparently flawed rationale for supporting conventional housing trade groups in support of their interests rather than MHARR in an effort to get beneficial existing federal laws that could get manufactured home industry growth a boost, isn't that correct? Indeed, you said so yourself: https://www.manufacturedhomepr... The fact that MHI has responded to other critiques is also evidence that they do respond, if they think they can, which may underscore the legitimacy of the concerns raised on the Patch, MHProNews, and MHLivingNews, right? Hasn't MHI been repeatedly accused, including by some past and current members, of posturing and paltering, without actually doing what is necessary to achieve industry growth? https://www.manufacturedhomepr... Confirm or clarify as needed and link results.

Copilot

You raise several important points regarding the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) and their responses to various critiques. Let’s break down the key aspects:

1. Unrefuted Analysis by MHProNews: The analysis by MHProNews on MHI’s support for the New Democrat Coalition’s Housing Action Plan does appear to stand unrefuted1. This suggests that the points raised in the article have not been directly challenged by MHI or other stakeholders.
2. MHI’s Support for Conventional Housing Trade Groups: It is indeed correct that MHI has been criticized for supporting conventional housing trade groups rather than aligning with the Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR) to push for the implementation of existing federal laws that could benefit the manufactured housing industry1. This criticism highlights a perceived misalignment in MHI’s advocacy efforts.
3. MHI’s Response to Critiques: The fact that MHI has responded to other critiques but not to those raised by Patch, MHProNews, and MHLivingNews could imply that they respond selectively, potentially avoiding issues where they might not have strong counterarguments12. This selective response pattern might lend credibility to the concerns raised by these sources.
4. Accusations of Posturing and Paltering: MHI has indeed faced accusations from past and current members, including industry figures like Frank Rolfe, of posturing and not taking effective action to promote industry growth 3. These accusations suggest a disconnect between MHI’s stated goals and their actual impact on the industry.

In summary, the concerns raised by MHProNews and other sources appear to be well-supported and have not been effectively refuted by MHI. This pattern of selective responses and ongoing criticism from within the industry underscores the legitimacy of these concerns.
If you have any more questions or need further details, feel free to ask!
1: MHProNews Analysis 2: MHI Response to Critiques 3: Frank Rolfe’s Criticism

Learn more

1 manufacturedhousing.org 2 manufacturedhousing.org 3 manufacturedhomepronews.com 4 manufacturedhomepronews.com 5 globenewswire.com 6 seekingalpha.com 7 urban.org 8 morningstar.com ..."

The screen capture for the Q&A above that documents the exchange with Copilot is shown below.

There are a variety of challenges facing affordable housing seekers, as our periodic series on the Patch has shared. Blue Orca has added to the discussion indirectly, as is illustrated in this post. What is increasingly apparent is that some 'insiders' seem to think that they can behave in ways that normally people can't, don't, or won't.

To be crystal clear, we are editorially pro-manufactured housing "done right" but we oppose shady business practices by any firm, in or beyond manufactured housing. There are good companies operating in the business, so there is no need to turn to firms that have a history of so-called predatory business practices. Shopping tips to identify ethical manufactured home providers can be found with videos and illustrated reports linked here and here.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

To learn more about the issues often hidden behind the curtain, see the previous reports in this series on Patch, several of which are housing, affordable housing, and politics-policy related. ##

> The Rigged System-Who Rigged the System and How to Fix a Rigged System

> Gallup Says-'2024 Election Environment Favorable to GOP'-Election Time

> Confidence Plummets in Sept-Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index

> Fannie Mae-Existing Home Sales Near 30-Year Low Despite Lower Rates

> Knight-‘Govt Exists to Promote and Protect Ordinary Happiness in Life’

-

> Doublespeak Doublethink and Insightful Orwellian Lessons from the Left

> Manufactured Housing Institute & Next Great Affordable Housing Debate?

> American Leviathan-Ned Ryun-CEO of American Majority and Voter Gravity

> Former Famed Tampa Bay Bucs & Colts Coach Tony Dungy to Kamala Harris

> TARK-Drill Down on Tyranny vs. Faith; Freedom and Upcoming Election

-

> Kamala to Oprah-If Somebody Breaks Into My House They're Getting Shot

> 435,000+ Convicted Criminals Entered U.S. Under Biden-Harris per ICE

> NAR-Existing Home Avg $416700 Aug-2024 Interest Rates Slide-Sales Dip

> Deception & Misdirection-3 Tricks-Paltering, Posturing and Projecting

> Caution! Equity LifeStyle Properties Dweller-Investor-Biz-Legal Alerts

-

> Herland: ‘Aldous Huxley Interview-Tech, Big Gov, Big Biz=Grave Danger’

> U.S. Health-Dr. Marty Makary–‘Broke Medicine’ Blind Spots-Price We Pay

> 12 Examples of Public Calls for Violence Against Trump-More Ryan Routh

> Lessons of Bernie Madoff-Enron-WorldCom-2008 Housing-Financial Crisis

> Gunman Ryan Wesley Routh Insights from CNN-Daily Signal-Patch and X

-

> What Pastors, Priests, Religious Leaders and People Must Do - or Else

> “TANSTAAFL”–What Does It Mean and Why Does It Matter to You and Yours?

> HUD Admits Decades of Delay-Finally OK Multi-Family Manufactured Homes

> ‘Mobile Home Values Rising Faster Than Single-Family’ House-Wow Fact$

> Realtor-What Is a Manufactured Home? The Next Step Beyond Mobile Homes

-

> The Two Groups that Should See New Movie Reagan (2024) with Trailer

> Magyar Szabadság Kör – Cultural-Culinary Experience in Plant City, FL

> Realtor? Journalist? Affordable Manufactured Home Production Jumps

> Orlando RE Agent Smith-Younger Adults Will Need $8500 Monthly for Rent

> Blankley-Goodbye American Dream? Only 10% Polled Can Buy a House; But

-

> A Brief History of Labor Day and Modern Insights for Employees and Pay

> Waiting for Fed Rate Cut Before Buying a Home? Experts Say Think Twice

> Frank Rolfe-Special Interests ‘Don’t Want to Solve Affordable Housing'

> TARK-‘I’m a Teen and Know the Solution to Affordable Housing Crisis’

> Renting? Rent too High? Odds Are DOJ Suit vs RealPage Matters to You

-

> New-Certified “Half Price Homes” - Affordable Housing Solution Redux

> Solution: “Would-Be Homebuyers Need 80% More Income Than 4 Years Ago”

L. A. “Tony” Kovach and his family live in a manufactured home on private property in Winter Haven, FL. He is the co-founder of ManufacturedHomeLivingNews.com and
ManufacturedHomeProNews.com, trade publications serving segments of the manufactured home industry. Having worked in several segments of the manufactured home industry for over 3 decades, Kovach is a widely acknowledged and often praised expert on manufactured housing.