Popular Italian Restaurant Closes Montclair Spot, Keeps Others Open

MONTCLAIR, NJ — A restaurant known among fans for its “old school Italian food” has closed its Montclair location, but continues to operate its other three eateries.

Scala del Nonna on Church Street in Montclair shut its doors Sunday after more than a decade in the township.

The restaurant also has locations in Chatham, Montville and New York City, which operate under the name of Scalini Fedeli.

Local foodies have gushed about the restaurant online, with one Yelp reviewer saying: “Old school Italian food that will make your heart happy! It truly feels like nonna is cooking and feeding you.”

Here’s the message that Scala del Nonna shared about the Montclair closing:

“It is with a heavy heart that we share the news that after 11 wonderful years, Scala del Nonna will be closing its doors. This is not just the end of a restaurant--it is the closing of a chapter that has been filled with laughter, love, and the warmth of family because that is exactly what you have been to us.

“You were never just customers. You were our friends who became family. We have watched your families grow, celebrated your milestones, toasted to your successes, and even grieved alongside you in difficult times. You have filled our dining room with stories, traditions, and moments that we will cherish forever.

“It has been an absolute privilege to serve you, to cook for you, and to share in the simple joys of a good meal surrounded by good company. Your support and loyalty have meant the world to us, and there are truly no words that can express our gratitude.

“Our doors will officially close on Sunday, February 16.

“But this is not goodbye--just a change of scenery. Please come visit our other locations, where you will always find the same delicious food, warm hospitality, and sense of family that you have come to know and love. We would be honored to welcome you with open arms and continue sharing meals, laughter, and memories together.

“From the bottom of our hearts, thank you for everything.”

Send local news tips and correction requests to eric.kiefer@patch.com. Learn more about advertising on Patch here. Find out how to post announcements or events to your local Patch site.