The Best Cupcakes On Long Island, As Chosen By Patch Readers

LONG ISLAND, NY — In honor of National Cupcake Day last week, we asked for recommendations of the best cupcakes made on Long Island, and boy, did you answer.

Unfortunately, there's no consensus on where the best cupcake is. But Patch readers had lots of recommendations for sweet teeth all across Long Island.

If you're looking for a yummy treat, here's a list of some favorites from our readers (in no particular order). And some reasons why these places stand out:

Tortafina Bake Shop and Pâtisserie in Babylon Village

• "Cupcakes and pies, cookies are amazing!!"

Cupcakes Galore in Bellport Village

• "Best cupcakes anywhere, not just Long Island."

Buttery Cookie Bakery in Floral Park, Huntington, and Manhasset

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by 𝐋𝐎𝐍𝐆 𝐈𝐒𝐋𝐀𝐍𝐃 𝐅𝐎𝐎𝐃 (@lifood.jpg)

Lavender Cupcakery and Dessert Shoppe in Hauppauge

• "Excellent variety, friendly staff, makes delicious occasion cakes as well!"

Cake Don Cupcakes in Huntington

• "His cupcakes are delicious, and his custom cakes are unbelievable. He was amazing during the height of COVID, delivering cupcakes all through Suffolk, Nassau and parts of Queens."

The Sweet Peace in Lynbrook.

• "She makes a holiday wreath made up of cupcakes which, like the rest of her offerings, are all sold out."

Crazy Cakes in Port Washington

• "An amazing nut-free place for cupcakes for eating at the cute café or take-out."

Fritzsche’s Bakery in Sayville

• "The best cupcakes, cookies, cakes and any other pastries you can think of!! Chocolate cake and icing are the best - worth every calorie!!"

Sweet Soul Bakery in St. James

• "Makes hands down best vegan, gluten-free cupcakes."

Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe in Westhampton Beach

• "They come in all different flavors and are delicious."

Audrey's Fine Baked Goods, West Sayville

Pride Enjoy in Wading River

The Sunflower Bakeshop in West Hempstead

• "She makes on request too! If you need anything gluten-free, sugar-free, dairy free, nut-free, etc. she’s got you. Prices are super reasonable too!"

Sydney's Sweets in West Hempstead

• "They made my wedding desserts AND won a Food Network competition. She has the ability to create works of art that taste good, even the fondant tastes like homemade marshmallows."