Politics & Government
The Lymes Election Results 2023: Vote Totals For Every Race
Here are the vote totals for every candidate that ran in the East Lyme, Lyme, and Old Lyme local elections on Tuesday, Nov. 7.

THE LYMES, CT — The votes have all been counted in East Lyme, Lyme, and Old Lyme, and here are the totals for each candidate.
Upon learning the results of today’s municipal election, Lyme Democratic Town Committee (DTC) Chairman John Kiker said in a statement, “On behalf of everyone at the Lyme DTC, I would like to thank the residents of Lyme for electing our full slate of highly qualified candidates, whose experience and expertise will benefit our town boards and commissions. We are particularly excited about the addition of Gavin Lodge to the Board of Education, which will help ensure the school board understands and reflects our values.”
The vote totals are courtesy of the Secretary of State website:
Find out what's happening in The Lymesfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
EAST LYME
First Selectman
Dan Cunningham, D, 2,747
Anne Santoro, R, 2,654
Find out what's happening in The Lymesfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Board of Selectman (voters selected up to three candidates)
Jason Deeble, D, 2,497
Ann Cicchiello, D, 2,879
Tony Attanasio, D, 2,290
Candice Carlson, R, 2,668
Don MacKenzie, R, 2,347
Rose Ann Hardy, R, 2,754
Board of Finance (voters selected up to three candidates)
Sandy Gignac, D, 2,762
Rich Steel, D, 3,050
Jay Ginsberg, D, 3,067
Lauren M. McNamara, R, 2,987
Board of Education (voters selected up to five candidates)
Esteban Garcia, D, 2,726
Vivek Purohit, D, 2,512
Steve Luber, D, 2,514
Cate Steel, D, 3,104
Jill Carini, D, 3,048
Olivia Fairchild, R, 2,588
Jaime Barr Shelburn, R, 2,637
Eric Bauman, R, 2,625
Board of Assessment Appeals (voters selected up to two candidates)
Michael Bekech, D, 2,528
Susan Graham, D, 2,746
Patrick Hughes, R, 2,465
Suzanne Szupiany, R, 2,314
Planning Commission (voters selected up to three candidates)
Brian Bohmbach, D, 2,816
Richard Gordon, D, 2,747
Nick Menapace, D, 3,046
Don Phimister, R, 2,302
Bonnie L. Smithers, R, 2,513
Planning Commission Alternate (voters selected up to two candidates)
Sam Sims, D, 2,594
Cindy Collins, D, 3,100
James Liska, R, 2,570
Zoning Commission (voters selected up to three candidates)
Gary Pivo, D, 2,606
Denise Markovitz, D, 2,826
Nancy Kalal, D, 2,950
Anne Thurlow, R, 2,556
Dave Schmitt, R, 2,304
Zoning Commission Alternate Full Term
Greg McIntire, D, 2,524
Marc Peterson, R, 2,263
Zoning Commission Alternate (two-year vacancy)
Sarah Susco, D, 3,125
LYME
First Selectman
David M. Lahm, R, 543
Selectmen
John Kiker, D, 562
Kristina Birgitta White, Pet., 178
Board of Finance
Steve Mattson, D, 618
David M. Brown, R, 424
Board of Finance (two-year vacancy)
Jim Miller, D, 680
Board of Finance Alternate
D. Adam McEwen, D, 652
Board of Finance Alternate (two-year vacancy)
Jeffery Oyster, R, 485
Board of Assessment Appeals
G. Hayden Reynolds, Jr., R, 509
Planning & Zoning Commission (voters selected up to three candidates)
Kristina White, D, 612
Frederick B. Gahagan, R, 419
William J. Fiske, R, 448
Planning & Zoning Commission Alternate
Mary Stone, D, 664
Zoning Board of Appeals (voters selected up to two candidates)
Anna James, D, 607
David S. Gage, R, 416
Zoning Board of Appeals Alternate
Henry A. Lahm, R, 503
Library Directors Full Term
John Kiker, D, 660
Regional Board of Education
Gavin Lodge, D, 587
Mary Powell-St. Louis, R, 347
OLD LYME
First Selectman
Martha H. Shoemaker, D, 1,830
John H. Mesham, R, 1,700
Selectman
Jim Lampos, D, 1,792
Judith Danenhower Read, R, 1,718
Town Treasurer
Michael Reiter, D, 1,702
Matthew P. Ward, R, 1,781
Tax Collector
Bonnie A. Reemsnyder, D, 1,675
Suzanne Thompson, R, 1,826
Board of Finance (voters selected up to two candidates)
Anna S. Reiter, D, 1,856
Bennett J. Bernblum, D, 1,876
Harold P. Garvin III, R, 1,798
Board of Finance Alternates (voters selected up to three candidates)
Diane Linderman, D, 1,827
Sheila A. Riffle, D, 1,706
Candace A. Fuchs, D, 1,846
Maria Corrao Marchant, R, 1,691
Matthew Olson, R, 1,751
Board of Assessment Appeals
Peter Hunt, D, 1,745
David W. Evers Jr., R, 1,728
Planning Commission Five Year Term Begins 2023
Michael Aurelia, D, 1,771
Barbara B. Gaudio, R, 1,681
Planning Commission Five Year Term Begins 2024
Howard Margules, D, 1,787
Donald Willis, R, 1,667
Zoning Commission Five Year Term Begins 2023
Paul J. Orzel, D, R, 3,383
Zoning Commission Five Year Term Begins 2024
Denise Savageau, D, 1,725
Tammy Tinnerello, R, 1,697
Zoning Board of Appeals Five year Term Begins 2023
Stephanie Mickle, D, 1,777
Daniel Montano, R, 1,641
Zoning Board of Appeals Five year Term Begins 20234
Nancy Hutchinson, R, 2,074
Zoning Board of Appeals Alternates (voters selected up to three candidates)
Kathleen Tracy, D, 1,768
Michaelle Pearson, D, 1,821
Brian Cole, R, 1,812
Peter Lucchese, R, 1,574
Rod Clingman, R, 1,758
Regional Board of Education (voters selected up to three candidates)
Alexander Lowry, D, 1,727
W. Scott Brown, D, 1,772
Susan P. Fogliano, D, 1,864
Suzanne Thompson, R, 1,722
Michael Presti, R, 1,614
Steven J. Wilson, R, 1,518
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.