Restaurants & Bars

See Dave Portnoy's 'One Bite' Reviews For 3 Morris County Pizzerias

Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports, visited local pizza shops in Morristown, Madison, and Denville recently - and the reviews are in.

Portnoy, who has traveled the country seeking to try every pie, recently sampled slices from Coniglio's Old Fashioned in Morristown, Krust Kitchen in Madison, and Cafe Crevier in Denville.
Portnoy, who has traveled the country seeking to try every pie, recently sampled slices from Coniglio's Old Fashioned in Morristown, Krust Kitchen in Madison, and Cafe Crevier in Denville. (Ellyn Santiago/Patch)

MORRIS COUNTY, NJ — Three more Morris County eateries have been added to the "One Bite" review list, a popular pizza-rating website and video series by Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy.

Portnoy, who has traveled the country seeking to try every pie, recently sampled slices from Coniglio's Old Fashioned in Morristown, Krust Kitchen in Madison, and Cafe Crevier in Denville.

The Massachusetts native orders a cheese pizza at every stop, noting the appearance and style before he takes "one bite" and gives his commentary on the flavors and crust.

Find out what's happening in Morristownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Each pizza place is given a rating out of 10, with only one perfect 10 on record — back in 2015, at Monte's Restaurant in Lynn, Massachusetts.

Portnoy, aka "El Presidente," has been a frequent visitor to the Garden State in this long-running series and is a big fan of thinner, bar-style pies.

Find out what's happening in Morristownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Here's what he said about his recent trips, with YouTube videos of the reviews linked.

Coniglio's Old Fashioned, 11 South St, Morristown:

Portnoy is friends with Brooklyn-born owner Nino Coniglio, and took a tour of the restaurant — as well as trying one of their Brooklyn Round pies with basil and fresh mozzarella. "I like this one better," Portnoy said of the traditional cheese pie. "(Coniglio) is a legend in the pizza game."

Score: 8.3

Krust Kitchen, 7 Cross Street, Madison: "This is good," he said after his first bite, noting he prefers more crunch in a thin pizza. Portnoy also walked into the small pickup and delivery restaurant, which turns out a variety of different pies.

Score: 7.3

Cafe Crevier, 25 East Main Street, Denville:

"It does look like I'll love it," said Portnoy, after commenting he has tried owner Nick Conforti's pizza at past location Angeloni's and given it an 8.8. "It's outrageously good," he quickly decided, noting that he rarely gives out 8.8s anymore. "Spectacular pizza."

Score: 8.5

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.