Here's Which Brooklyn Bagel Shops Made It To Yelp’s Top 100

BROOKLYN, NY — The verdict is in: The top 100 bagel shops in New York have been ranked for 2024, and 13 Brooklyn-based shops have joined the ranks, including Knickerbocker Bagel in Bushwick and LaBagel Delight in Park Slope.

The definitive list was devised by Yelp, the popular business-rating website, using its own data from user-generated reviews of bagel shops throughout the state.

This is the first time Yelp has released a ranking of this sort. According to Yelp, several factors went into the scores, like the total volume and ratings of reviews.

Yelp officials said that all businesses on this list had a passing health score as of Aug. 5.

“When it comes to bagels, Brooklyn doesn't mess around," Morlene Chin, Yelp Brooklyn Senior Community Director, told Patch over email.

"We have both classic joints that have been holding it down for decades, as well as the newer kids on the block bringing fresh energy to the bagel game like Mixtape Bushwick (#23), La Bagel Delight (#26), and Bagel World (#28).”

Here is Yelp's full list from across the state:

1. PopUp Bagels, Manhattan
2. Liberty Bagels Midtown, Manhattan
3. Best Bagel & Coffee, Manhattan
4. Between the Bagel, Astoria, Queens
5. Water Street Bagel, Syracuse
6. Russ & Daughters, Manhattan
7. Absolute Bagels, Manhattan
8. Apollo Bagels, Manhattan
9. Willie’s Bagel Cafe, Utica
10. Ess-a-Bagel, Manhattan
11. Bear’s Cup, Bolton
12. Sunrise Bagel & Deli, Kingston
13. Bagels Santa Fe, East Meadow
14. Broad Nosh Bagels & Deli, Manhattan
15. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company, Manhattan
16. Utopia Bagels, Whitestone, Queens
17. BTS – Bagel To Sandwich, Manhattan
18. Pio Bagel West, Manhattan
19. The Bagel Shop and Deli, Middletown
20. Brownstein’s Deli and Bakery, Rochester
21. Tompkins Square Bagels – 2nd Ave., Manhattan
22. Empire Bagels, Bronx
23. Mixtape Bushwick, Brooklyn
24. Tomi’s Bites, Hopewell Junction
25. Undergrounds Coffee House and Roastery, Buffalo
26. La Bagel Delight, Brooklyn
27. Bagel Train, Suffern
28. Bagel World, Brooklyn
29. DeWitt Bagel Co., DeWitt
30. The Bagel Emporium – Tarrytown, Tarrytown
31. Downtown Bagels, Middletown
32. Railroad Bagel Express, Babylon
33. Rico Bagel, Manhattan
34. Heaven’s Hot Bagel, Manhattan
35. H & L Bagels, Brooklyn
36. Bagels & Schmear, Manhattan
37. Knickerbocker Bagel, Brooklyn
38. BO’s Bagels, Manhattan
39. Baker’s Dozen Bagels, Kew Gardens, Queens
40. NY Bagels & Cafe, Manhattan
41. Scarsdale Bagels, Scarsdale
42. Mike’s Bagels, Manhattan
43. Country Hot Bagels, Northport
44. Uncommon Grounds Coffee & Tea, Saratoga Springs
45. NY Jumbo Bagels, Manhattan
46. Bagel Boy, Brooklyn
47. Broad Street Bagel, Kinderhook
48. Nyack Hot Bagels, Nyack
49. Bagelworks, Manhattan
50. Barney Greengrass, Manhattan
51. Astoria Bagel Shop & Deli, Astoria, Queens
52. Zabar’s, Manhattan
53. Broadway Bagel, Manhattan
54. New York City Bagel & Coffee House, Astoria, Queens
55. Pearl’s Bagels & Bakery, Albany
56. The Bagel Emporium – Yorktown Heights, Yorktown Heights
57. Baked in Brooklyn Bakery Store, Brooklyn
58. Bagel Land, Rochester
59. Shelsky’s of Brooklyn Appetizing & Delicatessen, Brooklyn
60. Wally’s Bagels, North Babylon
61. Park Place Bagels, Bronxville
62. Bagel Market, Manhattan
63. Monticello Bagel, Monticello
64. Eastdale Ave Bagels, Poughkeepsie
65. Boardwalk Bagel, Atlantic Beach, Queens
66. JK Bakery, Flushing, Queens
67. Modern Bread and Bagel, Manhattan
68. Turnpike Bagels Deli & Bakery, Levittown
69. Toast & Roast Bagels and Coffee, Astoria, Queens
70. Rhinebeck Bagels & Cafe, Rhinebeck
71. Glendale Bagels & Quality Deli, Glendale, Queens
72. Smith Street Bagels, Brooklyn
73. Bagel Parlor, Whitestone, Queens
74. H&H Bagels, Manhattan
75. Bagels & Bakes, Schenectady
76. Bagel Bob’s, Manhattan
77. David’s Bagels, Manhattan
78. Have-a-Bagel, Brooklyn
79. Collegetown Bagels, Ithaca
80. Lox of Bagels, Saugerties
81. Goldberg’s Famous Bagels & Deli, Yonkers
82. Zimi Bagel Café, Pearl River
83. Harrison Bagels, Harrison
84. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys, Manhattan
85. Bagel Plaza, Merrick
86. Hot Bagels, Brooklyn
87. Whitestone Bagel Factory, Whitestone, Queens
88. Bagel Bazaar, Brooklyn
89. Rockaway Bagels, Rockaway Park, Queens
90. Sam’s Bagels, Brooklyn
91. A&S Bagels, Franklin Square
92. Bagels on the Square, Manhattan
93. Bagels & Brew, Astoria, Queens
94. Bagels & More, Manhattan
95. Bagel Oasis, Fresh Meadows, Queens
96. My Three Sons Bagel Cafe, Stewart Manor
97. Village Bagel, Syosset
98. Bergen Bagels, Brooklyn
99. Hot Bialys & Bagels, Forest Hills, Queens
100. Pantano’s Doz Bagels, Garden City Park