How Identity Politics is Hurting the People of East Harlem

Historically, East Harlem has had Hispanic, more specifically Puerto Rican, representation at a time when these voices weren’t centered in politics. This representation was crucial in addressing the community's needs and concerns. Leaders like García Rivera & Olga Mendez were instrumental in advocating for our community. Over the years, the community has continued to maintain a strong home for Puerto Ricans, including a large Afro-Latin@ population that enriches our cultural diversity. However, identity politics can sometimes create divisions and hinder unity by focusing too much on differences rather than shared goals and values.

Just this week, the State Assembly race in the 68th District has recently been marred by controversy, with mailers from Assemblymember Edward Gibb’s campaign falsely implying endorsements from several prominent politicians, who have not actually supported him. These mailers have been rightly called out by some of these politicians, which inaccurately list endorsements from Gov. Hochul, Lt. Gov. Antonio Delgado, and others. Many question why a candidate would risk everything, including their race, for such a misleading tactic.

Currently, the race in East Harlem is between four candidates who are split between the Black and Puerto Rican identities that define our diverse community. This has garnered significant attention, which could be one reason why the pressure to lie in campaign literature has emerged. However, there are other underlying historical issues at play, notably identity politics. Without addressing the role of identity politics, we can’t fully understand the dynamics at play in the State Assembly race in the 68th District.

Beyond this controversy, lies a more pressing issue: the need to prioritize community-focused leadership and attention to those most impacted by a lack of representation. We need leaders who will work to end open-air drug use in our community, protect our affordable housing, and help seniors age in place without the fear of displacement.

Currently, the race is being reduced to a simplistic narrative of identity and racial politics. Yes, the 68th District is diverse, and its representation should reflect its vibrant demographics. But more important, our representative should be someone who can effectively address our challenges. Continuing to play into racial politics risks something hurtful happening to our community.

The controversy surrounding the incumbent’s mailer should serve as a reminder of what is truly at stake in this election. It's not about which politician can garner the most high-profile endorsements but about who can deliver real results for our community.

As we approach election day, let’s focus on what truly matters. We need a leader who understands our community's unique challenges and has the vision and determination to address them. We need Tamika Mapp. Let's ensure that our vote reflects our desire for genuine, community-focused leadership.